Ramblings, Uncategorized

Update: Eleanor Oliphant Is…American?

I have just found out that the film/TV rights to Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine have been bought up by Reese Witherspoon’s production company. Whilst I am a fan of Reese Witherspoon (I loved what she did with Big Little Lies and her Instagram is just lovely – plus, she’s Elle Woods!) it doesn’t prevent the fact that I am a little nervous about an adaptation of a book which so quickly found a special place in my heart.

My biggest fear is that they will change the setting of the book to somewhere in the US. Whilst the themes of Eleanor Oliphant are completely universal and I feel that people everywhere can connect to her, there are some quaint elements of the story that are so uniquely British that I fear we would lose them if Eleanor were to become an American. The Tesco shopping, bus rides around Glasgow, trips to the pub, Sammy’s Irn Bru (which isn’t even legally allowed into the US!) and the unglamorous British way of life are all aspects we may lose should Eleanor move stateside. This was one of the reasons I feel that the film of The Girl on the Train was so lacklustre in comparison to the novel, it wasn’t able to truly capture the miserable London commute and our often pessimistic (without being too tragic) outlook on life – I really don’t want this to happen to Eleanor, her story deserves better.

I know that Ms Witherspoon is an avid reader, and really enjoyed the faithful adaptation of Gone Girl on which she was a producer, so can only hope that she does the book justice and perhaps keeps Eleanor at home in Blighty.

Advertisements
Uncategorized

Beauty and the Beast Ponderings

This is not a book, I know. The only way I can think of linking it into my aim for this blog is that Belle is a book-loving princess?

I’m not going to do a review of the film (although I must admit that after going in with low expectations I was pleasantly surprised), but I had some stray thoughts while watching it and wondered if anyone else thought the same.

Please also note that there will be spoilers ahead and, whilst much of the film follows the beats of the original, there are some changes which I comment on below.

The Beast likes books
The fact that Beast couldn’t read never made sense to me. Before being turned, he was an 11 (?) year old born into royalty, so surely he must have been taught to read at some point?! I know that in the original film Belle and the Beast bonded when she taught him to read, but I think that Belle discovering someone else who enjoys reading seems like a more organic way to have her warm to him.

Also, surely in all that time he would have read as a form of entertainment? 10 years is a long time alone in that castle with such a big library!

The dance sequence
This was beautifully done as expected, if not quite as technically groundbreaking as the original. However, due the heavy use of CGI on the Beast, I could not quite suppress the image of Dan Stevens wearing a green body suit whilst dancing and staring romantically into Emma Watson’s eyes.
Please tell me that this is how it was filmed and please let there be footage somewhere.

Gaston doesn’t get a chance to remember 
So at the end of the film we learn that Belle’s quiet village was also put under the curse and had forgotten all about the castle and their loved ones who worked there (as is evidenced by Mr & Mrs Potts’ reunion). So what about Gaston? Maybe Gaston really had a lady love or family in the castle whom he forgot? We will never know if Gaston’s true self was perhaps a little less self-centred and he was just lonely all this time.